Monday, seven forty. The coordinator's phone vibrates: an educator has a fever and will not come. The first question is not who can replace her. It is another, more urgent one: with the children arriving this morning, are we still in compliance with the numerical ratio? And the answer, surprisingly, depends on where the nursery is located.
The ratio of educators to children is one of the most cited and least understood requirements in detail. There is no single number valid throughout Italy: it changes from Region to Region, and the way to calculate it also varies. In this article, we will see who establishes it, some verified examples of regional regulations, why the calculation base weighs as much as the number, and what it entails for quality, shifts, and accreditation.
Who decides the numerical ratio
For nurseries, there is no ratio set by national law. Legislative Decree No. 65 of April 13, 2017, which established the integrated 0-6 system, entrusts the Regions with the task of defining the structural, organizational, and quality standards of educational services for children. Municipalities are responsible for authorization, accreditation, and supervision, in compliance with those standards.
There is a national exception: the spring sections for children between 24 and 36 months. According to the criteria referred to by the Ministry of Education and Merit based on the 2013 Framework Agreement, the educator-child ratio must not exceed 1 to 10, with homogeneous age groups of between 10 and 20 children.
For everything else, the reference is the regulations of one's own Region, along with any municipal regulations.
Four Regions, four ways of counting
Here are some examples, verified against the texts in force at the time of publication. This is not a complete list, and the regulations may change: before organizing staff, always check the updated text of your Region.
- Emilia-Romagna (directive approved with DGR 1564/2017): no more than 5 children per educator between 3 and 12 months, 7 between 12 and 24 months, 10 in sections that exclusively welcome children between 24 and 36 months. Every enrolled child is counted, and the ratios are understood as daily averages.
- Tuscany (regulation 41/R of 2013, article 27, in the updated text): no more than 6 children per educator under 12 months, 7 between 12 and 23 months, 10 between 24 and 36 months. The ratio refers to at least 80 percent of the enrolled children.
- Lombardy (DGR XI/2929 of 2020, which amended DGR 20588/2005): one socio-educational operator for every 8 present children, for at least 7 hours of activity. In the remaining two hours, the ratio can drop to 1 to 10, ensuring co-presence.
- Lazio (regional law 7/2020, article 35): one educator for every 7 children, calculated on the total number of authorized places. For spring sections, the same law indicates one educator for every 10 children.
The calculation base weighs as much as the number
Listing the numbers is not enough. The four regulations count different things.
- By age or with a single parameter. Emilia-Romagna and Tuscany distinguish between infants, middles, and large children. Lombardy and Lazio use a single parameter, leaving the organization to the manager.
- Enrolled, present, or authorized places. A ratio calculated on enrolled children or authorized places is defined at the beginning of the year. One calculated on present children must be verified every day, as it depends on who actually walks through the door.
- Averages or time slots. In Emilia-Romagna, we talk about daily average ratios. In Tuscany, shifts must ensure the ratio during different time slots and maximum co-presence among educators. In Lombardy, the full ratio applies during activity hours.
An example helps. A group of 14 children between 12 and 24 months requires 2 educators both with the Tuscan parameter and the Emilian one. The same group, in a Region with a single parameter, is included in the overall calculation of the structure. The final number may coincide, but the organizational logic does not.
Mixed sections and critical moments of the day
Many nurseries work with heterogeneous sections by age. The Emilian directive asks in this case to define the ratio "in due proportion" concerning ages, children's autonomy, and opening times, ensuring adequate co-presence. The Lazio law recognizes the manager's possibility to organize with heterogeneous sections, provided the parameter is respected.
Then there are the moments of the day when the ratio is more fragile: morning welcome, when children arrive in waves, lunch, naptime, and departure. These are also the moments when an unexpected absence is felt the most. It is there that the coverage of shifts must be looked at more closely, not just the total for the day.
Why it matters, beyond the obligation
The Emilian directive states at the outset: the numerical ratio between staff and children "is one of the main elements that contribute to determining the quality of services." The national pedagogical guidelines for zero to six, when talking about spring sections, specifically mention the more favorable numerical ratio as one of their quality traits.
In practical terms, an adequate ratio means:
- time for individual relationships, especially during transitions, meals, and sleep for the youngest;
- security, because every child has an adult who sees them;
- the possibility to work in small groups and not keep everyone waiting at the same time;
- less fatigue for educators, who work better and stay longer.
The legal minimum is the threshold below which one does not go. It is not necessarily the ideal number for one's educational project.
What changes for shifts, replacements, and accreditation
The numerical ratio enters into three organizational choices.
- Shifts. They must be constructed starting from the actual curve of attendance during different time slots, not just from the number of enrolled children. We discussed this in managing educational staff in nurseries.
- Replacements. It is necessary to know in advance who can cover an absence and with what qualifications, because the staff counted in the ratio must meet the requirements set by the regional regulation.
- Accreditation. The numerical ratio is among the requirements already verified for authorization and supervision. The accreditation requirements, where provided, may be higher than the minimums and in some Regions are defined by the Municipalities based on regional criteria.
It should also be noted that some collective agreements may provide for more favorable conditions, which remain valid. The Emilian directive specifies this explicitly.
A checklist for the coordinator
- Retrieve the updated text of the regional regulation and any municipal regulation, and note the date of the last modification.
- Check what the ratio is calculated on: enrolled, present, or authorized places, by age or with a single parameter.
- Map the attendance by time slot for at least two typical weeks and compare it with the shifts.
- Prepare a replacement plan with names, titles, and availability.
- Keep the evidence: attendance of children and staff is proof of compliance with the ratio, as explained in the attendance register as proof.
- For doubtful cases, ask for an opinion from the competent municipal office or your consultant.
A digital attendance register, updated in real-time, makes it easier to see how many children are present at any moment and compare them with the staff on duty.
In summary
The ratio of educators to children in nurseries is not the same throughout Italy: it is set by the Regions, with different numbers and calculation methods. Emilia-Romagna and Tuscany reason by age groups, Lombardy counts present children, and Lazio counts authorized places. For spring sections, the national reference of 1 to 10 applies. Knowing your regulation well, and the base on which it is calculated, is the first step to building sustainable shifts, facing checks with serenity, and ensuring children have the time they need.
If you want to have the attendance of children and staff always updated in one place, you can try Easy.School for free.